Hoyong “Blue” Choi

푸름 (최호용)

I am a researcher in East Asian philosophy and comparative philosophy, based in Edmonton, Canada. I am especially interested in Pre-Qin Chinese philosophy, Neo-Confucianism, Existentialism, and New Materialism.

I am an M.A. student in the Department of East Asian Studies at the University of Alberta, working with Professor Daniel Fried. Before this, I completed a B.A. in Religious Studies and Psychology (summa cum laude) and an M.A. in Religious Studies at Sogang University in Seoul, under the supervision of Professor So-yi Chung.

Blue is my preferred name and Hoyong Choi is my legal name. I go by Blue because 푸름 (Pureum), my Korean preferred name, means “blue” in Korean.

PublicationsCV

Hoyong “Blue” Choi

Recent work

2026

Is the Nature of Robots Good?

로봇의 본성은 선한가?

In Hanpyeon (《한편》), no. 20 (special issue: Robot), 57–76. Seoul: Minumsa, 2026. In Korean.

A short, accessible essay that brings robots into the Horak debate of late Joseon Neo-Confucianism on whether human and nonhuman natures are the same (人物性同異論爭).

“If we grant that a robot can be born—or rather, made—with an a priori good nature, could we then say that its nature is qualitatively the same as a human’s?”
2025

Re-examining Horizontal Teacher-Student Relationships in Korean Confucianism: Focusing on the Cases of Toegye and Seongho

조선 유학에서 수평적 사제 관계 재조명: 퇴계-제자, 성호-제자 간 관계 분석을 중심으로

With Bo Hyeouk Kang. Education Review (교육비평), no. 58 (2025): 233–86. In Korean.

Third prize, Education Review paper competition

Argues that the “authoritarian” image of the Confucian teacher-student relationship is a distortion, and shows how Confucius, Toegye, and Seongho practiced mutual respect, individualized guidance, and open exchange.

Abstract

In contemporary Korean society, the term ‘Confucian’ is often used to refer to negative and hierarchical human relationships. In the field of education as well, when the teacher-student relationship is described as ‘still Confucian,’ it frequently points to an authoritarian and hierarchical structure. However, this perception is a distorted interpretation of the original values of Confucianism, and in fact, teacher-student relationships in the Confucian tradition were not hierarchical. Therefore, using the term ‘Confucian’ in this way is not justified. Looking at the original Confucian teacher-student relationship as revealed in the Analects, it is clear that Confucius valued mutual respect and deep understanding of each student over unilateral authority in his relationships with disciples. Confucius identified the strengths and weaknesses of his students to provide tailored advice, and he fostered a close atmosphere by incorporating humor and jokes. While students respected their teacher, the teacher also acknowledged the excellence of his students and willingly accepted their differing opinions. The leading Joseon Confucian scholars, Toegye Yi Hwang and Seongho Yi Ik, also demonstrated educational philosophies similar to Confucius. Toegye emphasized self-directed learning and close reading, providing education suited to each student’s level. He was affectionate yet strict, and gladly accepted logical counterarguments from his students. Likewise, Seongho warned against closed-mindedness and valued open dialogue with his students. He criticized exam-oriented education, stressed self-attainment, and, like Confucius and Toegye, welcomed students’ differing opinions. Both scholars practiced mutual respect and horizontal communication rather than asserting authority in their relationships with students. Thus, the original Confucian teacher-student relationship was not authoritarian; its core lay in mutual respect, understanding, individualized guidance, and free exchange of ideas. If, in contemporary Korean society, ‘Confucian’ is taken to mean a strictly hierarchical order, this stems from a misunderstanding far removed from its original meaning. If we recover the true spirit of the Confucian teacher-student relationship, an educational culture could be established in which students can freely express their opinions to teachers, and teachers accept them with an open mind—a horizontal and humane culture. By reexamining tradition, we can hope for a healthy ‘Confucian teacher-student relationship’ centered on mutual respect and communication, rather than one-sided obedience.

2025

The Concept of Love in Laozi’s Daodejing

노자 『도덕경』에서 사랑의 개념

Master’s thesis, Sogang University, 2025. In Korean.

Clarifies the concept of love (ci’ai, 慈愛) in the Daodejing and argues that the sage’s love is “heartless love” (無心之愛), grounded in the effort to move beyond artificial heart-mind.

Abstract

This dissertation aims to clarify the concept of love (ci’ai, 慈愛) in Laozi’s Daodejing (Classic of the Way and Virtue). The term ‘love’ (ci, 慈), particularly as it appears in Chapter 67, has been subject to a wide range of interpretations and commentaries. Nevertheless, its meaning remains highly contested and ambiguous, with no single, widely accepted interpretation. In order to fully grasp the precise meaning of love in Laozi’s text, it is essential to understand the holistic structure of Dao and the human being within Laozi’s philosophy.

To this end, the dissertation first explores various conceptions of love in pre-Qin China. Whether in Confucianism, Mohism, or Daoism, despite differences in core doctrines and values, these traditions converge on a broad definition of love: the intention (heart/mind) to promote the well-being of others (the object of love).

The study then turns to a careful analysis of the overall structure of Laozi’s philosophy, focusing on the respective workings of Dao and the human. For Laozi, Dao is devoid of heart and mind; its operation is characterized by natural, non-artificial action (wuwei, 無爲). In contrast, humans are endowed with heart and act through mind: they acquire knowledge, develop desires based on that knowledge, and act in accordance with those desires. If their knowledge is artificial, their desires and actions become artificial as well; if their knowledge is natural and sufficient, so too are their desires and actions.

Within Laozi’s thought, the practitioners of love (ci’ai) are the sages. Sages are so named because they possess and embody ci’ai, the first of Laozi’s Three Treasures (三寶). They look to the non-artificial operation of Dao and recognize it as the ultimate form of love—the most fundamental way to enable human flourishing. Yet, as human beings, sages cannot help but act from their own heart-mind. Thus, they strive to be without knowledge, without desire, and ultimately without heart-mind, in order to act through non-action. The love of sages, grounded in this effort to transcend artificial heart-mind, may be termed ‘heartless love’ (無心之愛). This form of love underlies their leadership and is expressed through their practice of non-action.

Dao, being without heart-mind, is inherently non-benevolent. Sages, while possessing heart-mind, seek to empty themselves of artificial benevolence, thereby attaining non-benevolence. Dao interacts with all things impartially, without attachment; sages, emulating Dao, likewise strive to engage with all things without partiality. Heaven and earth regard all beings as straw dogs (芻狗), and sages similarly view people as straw dogs. Nevertheless, their actions, aligned with Dao, ultimately foster the natural well-being of all.

In conclusion, sages are able to practice non-action because they endeavor to be without heart-mind. Laozi’s notion of ‘heartless love’ offers a compelling framework for understanding how sages, as human beings, can follow the impartial, dispassionate, and non-benevolent workings of Dao.

Contact

The best way to reach me is by email.

hoyong@ualberta.ca
pureumblue@sogang.ac.kr